Will Basic Attention Token scale?

As someone who’s worked in digital advertising for over a decade and is very passionate about cryptocurrency and blockchains, I wanted to share some thoughts on one of the most notable ICO’s to date: Basic Attention Token. Not about how the ICO went which plenty has been written about, but instead about the business model and viability. (Disclosure: I work on ads at Facebook. I hold Ether, which underlies BAT. I have never held any BAT.)

Why is it so notable?

BAT ICO’d (I think that’s a verb by now: it’s like IPO’d but ‘c’ for coin) on June 1 and sold out in 30 seconds. This is a record. They only sold a fraction of their tokens and raised $30 million. It was also founded by the Brendan Eich who invented javascript and 3rd party cookies – technologies that touch billions of people everyday. Legend!

What does BAT do?

BAT creates a market for online advertising between users, publishers, and advertisers. It values each ad impression a users sees based on how much of the ad was seen and for how long. Also known as: attention. The amount of attention generated determines how much value the advertiser should transfer to the publisher. Users are cut into the deal and receive tokens for allowing ads in their browser aka “providing basic attention”. Note, this does not mean they actually looked at the ads or were in front of their browser at the time.

The premise makes sense on paper:

  • give users ultimate control over their digital ad experience
  • reward publishers based on how much business outcome they generate for advertisers
  • advertisers only pay for business outcomes

I agree with this approach (enable choice for users, enable advertisers to pay for outcomes and not proxies) because it’s exactly the same approach we take at Facebook. However, the details are much different.

  • The only advertiser outcome enabled in BAT is attention. In fact, the ‘A’ stands for attention. This is certainly better than paying for an impression (whether it was seen or unseen) or a click (whether it was from a human or a bot). We’re aligned there. But the advertising world has already moved to a pricing model based on high value events like someone making a purchase or applying for a credit card.
  • Optimization happens locally, in the browser. In other words, the system machine learns about which ads I like and don’t like based on my behavior, limited to me. This makes sense in a decentralized system. But optimization requires massive amounts of training data. That’s easiest with centralization but maybe BAT will find a way to aggregate data for machine learning yet still respect the promises they’ve made.
  • Today, it only works when users are on a BAT enabled browser. That’s developed by Brave but in the future they want to embed their technology all over. This will be the critical path to success. iOS, for example, doesn’t allow for anything custom beyond the standard webkit renderer. Also, mobile app monetization is huge and growing quickly. BAT can work there in theory, but will require a different implementation than their website implementation. Related to the point above, would BAT know that I’m the same person in a mobile app and a desktop web browser? Perhaps if they create a way for oneself to identify as the same BAT user in both. But you’d think this is a critical v1 feature to make sure a user is not getting too much attention of the same ad on both (BAT should know better).
  • Most importantly, the incentives are largely aligned with advertisers and users. There’s a bigger question on users and publishers, who generate the supply of inventory for BAT to be spent on. Will monetization teams at publishers be able to tell their CFO’s that this quarter they’re getting paid a bit of BAT, not all Euro? With Google’s ad network revenue declining (meaning the rest of the web getting paid less), will publishers take risks in trying something new and radical? Or just optimize what’s tried and true?

I love that the Brave / BAT team is being bold and taking combining two of my passions. But I am skeptical about anyone building a new two-sided market of advertisers and publishers at this stage of online advertising, particularly when limited to a user base that has to be acquired one at a time. If they can efficiently integrate their tech in a way to quickly saturate a specific user base, then they’ll be able to use advertiser demand for this method of transaction to spur publisher adoption.


Scott Shapiro

Product Marketing Director, Facebook Ads. Cryptocurrency enthusiast. Berkeley MBA. Paleo. Aspiring Mountaineer.


39 thoughts on “Will Basic Attention Token scale?

  1. Great read! very neutral analysis and nothing that I could add here. But I really feel team behind this project have capacity to put this plan on work. But it will be big a disruption in digital advertising!

  2. BAT concept looks cool and promising given the amount of click fraud happening.
    i see the underlying tech as having value but not the currency

  3. If you аre the type of person who is lower than tҺrilled wіth the prospect
    of workіnmg in the identіcal offiсe, day afteг day, eliminating
    thіѕ type of routine is without doubt ⲟne of the most important highlіghts that you would be able to receive from freelɑncing.
    Whenever уou hire youг sslf ouսt ass a freelancer, each and every job task that yoս simply take on will probably be a
    new adventure. Not soⅼely will the work envirоnment differ,
    howeveг additionally, you will have tɦe opportunity to meet many more attention-grabbing people.

    This fadtor alone iss likely one of the major explɑnation whyy many paralegals wsnt freelancing over committіng themselves too at least one partіcular

  4. Terrific article! That is the kind of information that are supposed to be shared across the net.
    Disgrace on the seek engines for not positioning this submit upper!
    Come on over and visit my website . Thank you =)

  5. Before you walk out to pay money for an outdoor stream
    spout you have to be sure you have a proper and good plan for your backyard of your home.
    The bacteria e-coli are mostly accountable for this.

    Then find some woodworking plans and patterns for a nice
    little wooden bridge for over your pond and you are done.

  6. Thanks for ones marvelous posting! I quite enjoyed reading
    it, you are a great author.I will make certain to bookmark your blog and will come back in the future.
    I want to encourage you continue your great job, have
    a nice day!

  7. Hello! I realize this is somewhat off-topic however I had to ask.
    Does running a well-established website such as yours take a lot of work?
    I’m brand new to operating a blog however I do write in my diary everyday.
    I’d like to start a blog so I can easily share my experience and views online.
    Please let me know if you have any ideas or tips for new aspiring blog owners.

  8. This design is incredible! You definitely know how to keep
    a reader entertained. Between your wit and your
    videos, I was almost moved to start my own blog (well, almost…HaHa!) Excellent
    job. I really loved what you had to say, and more than that,
    how you presented it. Too cool!

  9. Aside from the standard gameplay parts of Conflict Royale,
    there’s additionally the addictive nature of collectible card games, which
    come within the type of new units and spells which can be utilized on the battlefield.

  10. Pretty nice post. I simply stumbled upon your weblog and wanted
    to say that I’ve really enjoyed browsing your blog posts.
    In any case I will be subscribing to your feed and I hope
    you write once more soon!

  11. programme repas minceur femme produits minceur yves rocher avis recette muffin sale minceur the vert orthosiphon aide-minceur legging minceur teleshopping avis 101 recettes minceur pdf the vert minceur ventre plat produit xls minceur dim legging
    minceur avis corset minceur amazon marque biscuit minceur tarte tomate thon minceur
    juvamine minceur cure express effet secondaire carotte
    vichy minceur gayelord hauser minceur 5 en 1 the vert minceur floressance massage
    minceur definition cure minceur spiruline fruits minceur ventre
    idee menu minceur facile gelule minceur efficace 2016 programme sport minceur 2 mois

  12. Pingback: Google

Comments are closed.